Posted in
Veterinarian Article | Posted By - Dr. Charach | at 4:59 pm
Best of Journal Club and Dermatology Rounds:
Lead by Dr.Mike Charach DVM, BSc, Dipl. ACVD
- Dr.Charach attended a 2 year Veterinary Dermatology Residency at the University of Florida 1990-1992, he became board certified in 1994. He has performed Allergy Skin testing on over 1000 dogs (Since 1987) over 40 horses, and using the Karl Storz Video Otoscopy for 3 years to treat and diagnose problems and diseases of the ear.
Allergy testing & Successful Case Management (Dermatology Rounds)
Allergy skin testing helps diagnose and manage difficult allergy cases.
Case 1: “Daisy” Referred from Ashcroft BC
Exam & History
Daisy is a two year old spayed female Dalmatian with a one year history of severe non-seasonal pruritus. The pruritus is generalized but the two front legs are the worst. There is near complete alopecia of the two front legs from elbow to the paws.
Testing
Intradermal allergy skin testing is negative with a moderate reaction to flea.
A negative skin test for atopy suggests food allergy as the next most likely diagnosis. An elimination food trial was initiated. Daisy was given three weeks of antibiotics for a mild pyoderma and Daisy was fed a vet commercial “Hypoallergenic diet” of duck and potato. After 6 weeks, there was no improvement in pruritus. Daisy was then fed a home cooked fish and potato diet. Daisy’s pruritus was 90-100% better after about 4 weeks. Daisy was then successfully switched to a commercial vet fish and potato diet. Three months later, Daisy is still 100% better and all the hair has grown back on the two front legs.
Discussion
Blood tests for environmental allergies are virtually 100% positive therefore not very specific. I would estimate about 40% of our skin test are negative with the exception of house dust/ house dust mite. These negative skin tests tend to rule out atopy and greatly implicate food allergies (AFR). We have seen many Elimination food trials (EFT) fail when using “Commercial hypoallergenic diets”. Homemade food trials remain the gold standard for diagnosing food allergies.
Homemade Elimination food trials and Rayne Clinical Nutrition.-
A study about testing for food allergies in California was conducted by animal dermatologists. (Comparison of a commercial limited-antigen diet versus home-prepared diets in the diagnosis of canine adverse food reaction. Vet Ther. 2002 Fall; 3(3):244-51 by T. Tapp, C. Griffin, W. Rosenkrantz, R.Muse, M.Boord)
The abstract indicates the following:
- Twenty four owners with dogs suspected of having food allergies were asked to prepare a homemade elimination food trial for 6-8 weeks.
- After two weeks only fourteen of the original twenty four dogs (60%) were still willing to continue the home made food trial. Ten (40%) owners were not willing to continue the home made food trial.
- Eight of the fourteen dogs continued homemade food trial showed significant improvement over the 6-8 weeks.
- These eight dogs were subsequently switched to a veterinary commercial hypoallergenic diet of fish and potatoes.
- Four of eight dogs did well on this dog food while the other four immediately became symptomatic.
Discussion:
If would appear two things can be surmised from this study.
1) Elimination food trials utilizing homemade diets are better than commercial fish and potato “hypoallergenic” diet
2) These dermatologists had around 40% non-compliance with conducting a homemade food trial
We offer the owners an option of home cooking for their pets or purchasing Rayne Clinical Nutrition diets, for their elimination food trial. Rayne Clinical Nutrition is a local company that prepares home cooked single protein, single carbohydrate diets and delivers it to the clients.
Case # 2: “Benson” Dr.Charachs own dog
Exam & History
Many years ago I owned a 2 year old Dalmatian named “Benson”. In May, “Benson” developed generalized pruritus and erythema of ears, axilla, abdomen, legs, and paws. “Benson” was allergy skin tested. There were severe reactions to five weed pollens (4+) and everything else was completely negative. “Benson” received allergen shots (ASIT) initially they were given once weekly (day 1, day 8, day 15) within three days after the third injection (day 15), “Benson’s” erythematous skin and pruritus was at least 90% resolved. The injections were given every 2, 3, then 4 weeks. “Benson” was asymptomatic for the rest of the summer. No allergy shots were given in the winter and “Benson” remained asymptomatic. The next June, “Benson” started with the same symptoms. The pruritus responded completely to just two allergy injections three weeks apart. One more injection was required by the end of the summer (3 total). The third summer showed a mild return of symptoms, which again completely responded (100%) too just two injections of the weed allergens. After the third summer, “Benson” never had skin or ear problems again.
Discussion
“Every Dermatologist should own a Dalmatian”
Summary
1) Benson had a 100% response to allergy shots by day 18 of the ASIT after only 3 allergy shots
2) First summer 8 allergy shots, winter 0.Second summer 3 allergy shots, winter 0. Third summer 2 allergy shots. Allergies cured for the rest of his life
Q & A:
Why was this Dalmatian so successfully treated with ASIT?
Secret to Success:
1) Early diagnosis and treatment leads to faster, more complete response to ASIT and produce higher “cure rates”.
2) Early diagnosis and treatments contributes to fewer allergens having to be desensitized to and once again better cure rates.
3) Early diagnosis and treatment also meant in “Benson’s” case not having to deal with secondary infections during immunotherapy.
Practical “Allergy Shots” made easier and faster-
Allergy Specific Immuno Therapy (ASIT): Utilizing Accelerated Single Bottle/Reduced number and Frequency of Injection in a Propylene Glycol Vehicle. (ASB/RN & FI/PGV)
How does allergy specific immunotherapy (ASIT) work?
Successful immunotherapy usually is associated with the following results:
- Increase Treg cells
- Increase IL 10
- Increase blocking antibodies
Why is ASIT with propylene glycol superior to Aqueous based ASIT?
The addition of propylene glycol allows a slow release (depo effect) of allergens.
This slow release of allergens allows us to use a single full strength bottle.
| Propylene Glycol A.S.I.T. |
Aqueous A.S.I.T |
| 1 bottle |
3 bottles |
| 8 injections |
27 injections |
| Given once weekly then every 2-4 weeks |
Given every three days |
| 18 days-4 months to desensitization |
3-9 months to desensitization |
We refer to A.S.I.T with propylene glycol as ASB/RN &F/PGV A.S.I.T.
(Accelerated Single Bottle/Reduced number & Frequency/Propylene Glycol Vehicle Allergy Specific Immuno Therapy)